China’s Pain Points

Treating an Achy Economy

Chinese Economy lede

Here are some of China’s economic pain points: banks with growing levels of bad loans and local governments drowning in debt; state-dominated oligopolies suffocating private business; bad investment in the wrong places. That’s just what hurts now. Here are some chronic headaches: an aging population; a wide wealth gap; a lack of innovation that could make it hard for China to improve the lives of its middle-income citizens the way it lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty; underfunded health and pension systems; environmental degradation; water shortagescorruption; rigged courts. Add to all that a stock market that lost $4 trillion in value in a month and the slowest annual GDP growth in 25 years. Nobody knows all this better than China’s leaders, who have issued a raft of policies to deal with the problems arising from the country’s economic maturation. It’s not clear how far they are willing to go to fix the system — or stay out of the way and let it fix itself.

The Situation

Since rising to power in early 2013, China’s leaders have pushed ahead with dozens of planned reforms. The changes range from letting families have a second child to cracking down on bribe-taking to reducing state controls over foreign exchange and interest rates. Altogether they constitute the biggest policy shifts since at least the 1990s. How fast the changes will come is another question. China’s reform goals were left vague in 2013, allowing plenty of leeway for delays and results that fall short of expectations. Two overarching objectives have remained clear: ensuring the party’s right to govern, and transitioning from an economy reliant on exports and infrastructure investment to one fueled by domestic consumption and the guiding hand of the market. China’s engineering of an epic stock market boom and bust in 2015 showed its leaders frantically shifting course. The benchmark Shanghai stock index more than doubled in a year before its peak in June, then tumbled by a third in three weeks. The government intervened to halt the slide by barring major shareholders from selling stakes and suspending new offerings. The fiddling tarnished the idea that China is ready to relax the guiding hand of the state.


Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China
Source: National Bureau of Statistics of China

The Background

China completed its once-a-decade transfer of power to a new generation of leaders at the 2013 National People’s Congress after what many saw as a decade of inaction under President Hu Jintao and Premier Wen Jiabao. Expectations were high that President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang would follow through with reforms. Since then, however, the country has seen little concrete progress toward promises to control local-government debt, strengthen environmental protection and reform state-owned enterprises. One reason may be that China’s economic growth was 7.4 percent in 2014, the lowest since 1990, and slowed to 7 percent in the first and second quarters of 2015. The first default by a state-owned company in April 2015 signaled some willingness to let market forces take their course. Done right, China’s leaders may be putting the economy on the path to surpassing the U.S. as the world’s largest and making its citizens wealthier. On the other hand, the consequences for the world could be dire if China doesn’t manage to eliminate overcapacity, revive the property market and focus more on the quality of economic growth than on hitting prescribed annual targets.

The Argument

There are many factions inside China’s one-party state, including vested interests with a stake in preserving the system. Some want reforms like exchange-rate liberalization and a breakup of state monopolies. Others prefer more state control. Big state-owned companies and the families of communist leaders want to maintain benefits they have built up over the years. Local officials don’t always obey the central government because they have their own incentives to do what they think is best for their careers and their localities. Propping up the stock market added to suspicions that China is still reluctant to turn its back on a Soviet-style controlled economy. There’s danger for the party in doing too much or too little, in alienating domestic allies on the one hand or provoking capital flight if the economy or markets founder on the other. The added complication now is that the Internet, while controlled, has given voice to hundreds of millions of people, many of whom are clamoring for relief from pollution, corruption, injustice and inequality.

The Reference Shelf

First Published Nov. 12, 2013

To contact the editors responsible for this QuickTake:

Nick Wadhams at

Leah Harrison Singer at